Meida credit to Jerica Fagan.
A teddy bear named "Mohammad"
Kyle Ferguson | 12/13/07 | Opinion

Recently, a British teacher was sentenced to 15 days in Sudan jail followed up by immediate deportation from Sudan. What was her crime? She allowed her class of seven year olds to name the class teddy bear ‘Mohammad.’ Gillian Gibbons, the woman charged with this insult to the Islamic faith, was a teacher at a British run school in Khartoum, and considering what protestors were fighting for, she was lucky.

Muslim protestors gathered last Friday, many armed with blunt objects and swords, to call for Mrs. Gibbons’s death. Most of these faithful Muslims were angered that she was let off the hook with merely 15 days and a deportation after being threatened with 40 lashes and six months imprisonment. They considered the act of her allowing her class to name the stuffed animal an extreme insult against their Islamic prophet and founder of Islam, Mohammad.

As many of you can assume, this poor woman doesn’t really deserve any of the heinous punishments that many have thrust upon her. To us, she’s done nothing wrong that can’t be fixed with much more than a little talk and slap on the wrist. However, therein lays our issue: we want to impose our culture onto others. As I must admit I began to write this editorial with the belief that I would write about how completely absurd the faithful Muslims are for wanting such a terrible punishment for such a minute offense. Do not get me wrong though, I still believe that it is a major overreaction on their part and that they should learn not to take every slight notion as an insult to their religion, not to mention resorting to violence and aggression when confronting every single one of these issues as well. However, that is not my concern right now. What I am concerned with is that the majority of the Western world has almost no idea for what goes and what does not, with respect to the world’s religions.

There have been many cases where Western ignorance has insulted many other religions that do not have as many followers as our major religions do here. The image of the Hindu goddess, Lord Ganesha, has been thrust upon such things as designer shoes and toilet seats. These products were withdrawn of course, after a huge uproar from the Hindu community, but the issue remains; we have little to no respect towards other religious icons and have no idea what goes and what doesn’t when dealing with such issues.

Gillian Gibbons did not deserve any of the terrible punishments she was threatened with. The Islamic faith does not deserve to be insulted by ignorant outsiders. Neither should be something that should be merely overlooked. The general western populace needs a crash course on respect with regard to the world’s religions. The Muslims need to learn how to handle something as trivial as the name of a class of seven year olds’ teddy bear, and that it does not incite a punishment as sever as lashings, nor death.



Please keep in mind that this is a high school newspaper. Please make your responses professional and appropriate. Any comments deemed inappropriate will not be posted.
Name:
E-mail:
Subject:

Grizzly Weather
Gazette Podcast
NSPA
Name: Jennifer Spangler
Date & Time: Wednesday, February 27, 2008 09:39 pm
Subject: A teddy bear named "Mohammad"

Kyle has brought up a point that would not have crossed many people's minds. Most of us would have looked at this issue and instantly noted the absurdity of the protester's reactions and the proposed punishments. Our western culture views the whole issue as absurd, but the reality is that our vehement reaction is fueled by ignorance. We would impose our culture upon all other peoples of the world, but we do not take the time to understand them. I must profess that I am as guilty of this ignorance as most other people as I have not read any of the holy books of any religion or studied the traditions or cultures of them in any serious sense, but I try to be as open minded as possible in all my experiences, and I must say that it would seem to me to be common sense to study the culture (or at least the most important ins and outs) of any region I planned to travel to, especially if I planned on spending any significant amount of time there. So while the reactions of the protestors are on the extreme side, I can definitely see the point that Mrs. Gibbons is not entirely a blameless victim and she should probably at least apologize to the people that she has offended so grievously, and learn from the experience, realizing that knowing the local customs is important to anyone who plans on staying in another region for any length of time.


home | news | opinion | literature | sports | entertainment
©2007 Grizzly Gazette | about us | gazette@grizzlygazette.net
Wal-Mart - Porterville Recorder - Sierra View District Hospital - Dr. Buettner
Woodard Homes - Perkos - AGR Contracting - Exchange Club of Porterville - Law Offices of Robert Krase - Zonta Club of Porterville - Porterville Breakfast Lions Club